Nancy Lehrer "Open - Closed"

Life Happens in COLOR with Nancy Lehrer (Podcast 616)

Today I'm really happy to be able to bring you a conversation with Nancy Lehrer. Those of you that used to participate in our forum before we had to close it down due to the constant spamming, may well remember Nancy. She always had something useful and insightful to...

Thank you for visiting!

Martin Bailey has been releasing weekly podcasts and blog posts since 2005! Almost all of the 760+ posts here contain a full text article with photographs and illustations, and take at least one day, sometimes three to four days to produce.

You are welcome to listen to the Podcast with the audio player and follow along with the images discussed below.

If you value what we do, please consider a Patreon contribution of $3 or more to unlock the full text of more than 760 posts and gain access to the exclusive MBP Community. There are also higher tiers with various benefits, some including one-to-one Mentorship.

Please visit our Patreon site for full details, and take your photography to a whole new level! Become a Patron!
Existing Patrons please login to access posts and benefits. Thanks for being awesome!

Image Gallery

If no images are displayed here, please refresh your browser.

To view this content, you must be a member of Martin's Patreon at $3 or more
Unlock with Patreon
Martin Bailey
Martin Bailey is a nature and wildlife photographer and educator based in Tokyo. He's a pioneering Podcaster and blogger, and an X-Rite Coloratti member.
3 Comments
  • Christian Meermann
    Posted at 00:48h, 26 April Reply

    With so much praise of color in this episode, can you roughly imagine how often I involuntarily cringed and winced while listening?! ?
    Seriously, I think it was a thought-provoking episode. I wholeheartedly agree with your remark on images not making sense in black & white when they are in color. Just like Nancy apparently having to face the notion that street photography must be black&white, I often find myself having to justify myself for converting to black&white (e.g., “A sunset cannot work in black&white, it is all about the color. Why did you do it?”). And I often find those comments a little narrow-minded because obviously, those viewers didn’t even try to understand what I actually wanted to show.
    To me, from the viewer’s perspective, the question of black&white or color should be one of storytelling. If the photographer chose black&white, he or she might have wanted to emphasize something else than the color. And if Nancy decided to go for this vivid colors, then even I as a black&white photographer should try to understand the story she tried to convey with this decision.

    • Martin Bailey
      Posted at 09:50h, 26 April Reply

      Hi Christian,

      With both of us loving black and white so much, I’m with you 100%.

      There have been times when I’ve fought the decision to convert to black and white. Sometimes I want to create a cohesive set, and force myself to convert an image to black and white despite the color adding to the image. Generally though, when I do that, I keep a color version as well, and continue to use that as a single piece.

      I also mentioned a conversation with a friend recently about some of my Hokkaido work, which is mostly black and white even without a conversion, but I do occasionally keep some images in color, because it’s either an important part of the image, or it is simply too nice to throw away.

      You hit the nail on the head though; I agree that this is down to each individual photographer to decide. One of the images from this year’s Hokkaido trip that I kept was a sunset. The warm color was just too good for me to throw out, although I have to admit, I did try it in black and white, just in case. 🙂

      We all make our own decisions, and I think we are entitled to decide by ourselves, and don’t need to worry what others think. I agree that it’s narrow-minded to simply rule out one option or another when it’s really all just about our own personal expression. It’s our art afterall!

      Regards,
      Martin.

  • inancy
    Posted at 00:12h, 06 May Reply

    Christian:

    It is interesting for me to hear that you sometimes get feedback that you should not have processed something (your sunset) into black and white. I agree with both you and Martin, that the photographer decides the intent, and what I want to add is that it should be a real intent. The photographer makes an intentional decision on what they want to say and how to say it.

    I have a favorite image of mine from Ireland of a person walking down a forested path with a dog in spring. The image just screams “GREEN” and with that, I knew it would be converted to b&w in my portfolio. But beyond that fact, it relies on tonal contrasts in b&w. The white dog is in a shadow area – creating a tonal contrast. The person is wearing a jacket that is blowing, making it look like a cape, and is in silhouette against a sunny area of the path – another tonal contrast. The trees have all this beautiful texture – a third use of tonal contrast. (https://inancy.files.wordpress.com/2015/06/ireland_20150508_02176-edit.jpg)

    Thanks again for your comments and feedback.
    Nancy

Post A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.